Saturday, March 28, 2009

This is Outrageous!

I just found out that the convention center in Washington DC raised their wifi access price from $8.95 to $24.95. This is terrible. Especially since NCTM is encouraging attendees to blog and tweet at the conference. More about the conference in my next blog.

Monday, February 23, 2009

CLIME 2009 - Goals & Highlights

Last summer while attending the NCTM affiliates meeting in Philly I sent myself this post-dated “reminder” so I wouldn’t forget the goals that I wrote down at that time. Well the reminder worked because here I am writing my latest blog after taking a much longer break than expected. First I want to say that CLIME is an independent affiliate of NCTM which means that there isn't anyone knocking on my email door reminding me to help crank up the NCTM membership though I’m sure they wouldn’t mind if you joined. They even provided CLIME with a bit of financial support in that some of you endorsed CLIME when you signed up for NCTM membership and as a result we got a small "royalty". For the first time in years I’ve been able to use outside funds to (almost) pay for our annual affiliate dues ($90). So much for the business part of this entry. Onward to the goals part. One the things that CLIME does is to act as a lobbying group to encourage NCTM to continue to promote the effective use of technology in math education. As some of you may know that despite a CLIME initiated technology resolution approved at the Delegate Assembly last April, the NCTM board declined to upgrade technology use at the annual meetings saying it is too expensive. (See report.) This whole issue might have been overlooked if NCTM had not decided to drop computer workshops from their annual conferences and not replace them with anything as substantive that showcases and acknowledges that technology is not just a trivial luxury but one of NCTM’s principles. We also know that when the NCTM “powers that be” decides to do something that shows their interest in promoting technology they do it extremely well. Two cases in point: (1) the Illuminations site is one of the best of its kind and continues to grow. Most recently new additions were added to their fine collection after NCTM ran an Institute at their Headquarters in Reston last summer where invited math educators developed new activities and lessons. Another such institute is planned for this summer. (2) Another excellent resource is the ON-Math e-Journal which explores what’s possible with electronic media and so far has done an admirable job. Also on the Web 2.0 front NCTM chose to have a very limited, trial Blog presence on the NCTM website during the Salt Lake City meeting. But it looks like they will use Facebook instead for open discussion of NCTM issues and activities including feedback on their Illuminations activities. They're even on Twitter! “What’s Twitter?” you ask. David Pogue writes about in a New York Times piece. The Facebook site has seen very little traffic so far. So I encourage you to support their effort though I think it would have more traffic if they ran it on the NCTM site. Help put CLIME on the Map That’s all encouraging news. But with success can come the complacency that large conservative organizations can suffer from especially when important implementation of ideas are seen as way too expensive and thus undermine the vision that technology can offer. I encourage you to help me remind the NCTM board and leaders to not lose site of the vision that technology offers. One easy and fun way to do this is to support CLIME’s initiatives by putting CLIME on the map (literally) with your stamp of support by adding your "footprint" on the CLIME Google map. 
If you don't have a google account you can use your own email address to access google maps. Here's a good entry point for first time users. For more info about using Google Maps for collaboration go to this link. (If all else fails let me know and I can help you.)
Add your location to the CLIME map Here’s what you do. Click on this link and add to the map: 1) your location (school, home, business, or whatever you are comfortable with) on the CLIME Google Map that I've set up. (2) include a short message indicating your support.
I guess you can call this a Web 2.0 approach to signing a petition. So please take a few minutes and let me and the CLIME world know that technology is indeed worthy of its principle status and should be championed as such. NCTM Conference 09 Update The NCTM 09 Washington Conference sessions have been posted. I’ll take a closer look at the technology sessions in my next blog.

Monday, November 10, 2008

Capturing the Teaching Moment: Predicting Election Results – part 2

I was recently watching a pre-election podcast of the CBS McLaughlin Group show (clip below) in which John McLaughlin asked Pat Buchanan to predict the outcome of the presidential election.
 He said: "The outlook is [a] probable Obama victory." I paused the podcast at that point and thought that what Pat said was not exactly a hard call to make given the multimedia rendition of data that I just watched. I wondered at that point what he would have said if he was also asked to predict the margin of victory in percentage points. (I found out the answer later in the show but I didn’t know that at this point.) Here’s a summary of the show's pollsters' predictions. The point spread ranges from a low of 3 to a high of 15. I've added an additional pollster "pundit" which I affectionately call "Kid" Average and include this numerical wonder as a candidate for the best estimate prize as well. A question for you. If we could turn back clock to before the election results were known, which polster would you have bet on to have made the best projection (i.e. came closest to the final outcome based on the polls provided by McLaughlin?) I would have bet my money on "Kid" Average who as I found out later did reasonably well. (See spreadsheet below.) According to today's (11/10/08) CNN website Obama won by 6.6 percentage points. I used a simple average of the polls to come up with my prediction. The pollsters not only use averages but also more sophisticated regression methods to make their projections. Here's what is written in the FAQ page at pollsters.com: "In most cases, the numbers are not an "average" but rather regression based trendlines. The specific methodology depends on the number of polls available.
  • If we have at least 8 public polls, we fit a trend line to the dots represented by each poll using a "Loess" iterative locally weighted least squares regression.
  • If we have between 4 and 7 polls, we fit a linear regression trend line (a straight line) to best fit the points.
  • If we have 3 polls or fewer, we calculate a simple average of the available surveys.
So it's possible for students to see real applications of these techniques as they learn about statistical methods. Plenty of math here for students to sink their teeth into where the technology is integral to the discussion. Oh, yes. What prediction did Pat make in term of points? Check it out in this next clip. It sounds like John and some of the others could use a math tuneup or two. If you are one of those "i can't get enough of this" folks, the drama of the election is still playing out in some corners especially the race for the Senate in Minnesota. Currently Norm Coleman leads Al Franken by 206 votes! See http://www.fivethirtyeight.com/2008/11/more-minnesota-madness.html for the latest details.

Monday, November 3, 2008

Capturing the Teaching Moment: Predicting Election Results – part 1

What I would do on Monday (11/3/08): As you all know today is the day before Americans elect the next president of the United States. If I was a teacher in a classroom today, I would assign the following homework:
Students: I would like you to make a prediction about who will win the presidency and by how many percentage points. Write up your rationale for your prediction. On Wednesday, we’ll analyze your data and see who came up with the "best" prediction.
I suppose one “easy” way that a student may do this would be to go to a website like this one and see what the pundits are predicting. From the current (3:15pm 11/3/08) graph it is clear that Obama is the favorite to win. The 311 electoral votes predicted would top the required 270 votes necessary. So predicting Obama’s victory appears to be a safe bet. But what about the point spread? If you click on the map above you will go the website where the actual map is. If you hover the mouse over the map you get a state by state prediction of the point spread. But where do these numbers come from? If you notice there is a link on the left side and just below the map (above) that answers the question. Since I don’t have a class to work with today, I’m hoping that you might be willing to play along with me and send in your prediction with a rationale for the number of points you chose. (I’m using Google Docs Spreadsheet for this activity.) Go to questionnaire and post your entries. There is only a small window on the entry form so you might want to write out your response elsewhere and then copy and paste in the form. I’ll be back on Wednesday with an analysis and an explanation of how this exercise can illuminate important math ideas.

Thursday, September 18, 2008

NCTM Elections 2008

Dear friends of CLIME, If you are a member of NCTM you probably received your ballot for the upcoming NCTM elections (deadline: October 31st). Having been an NCTM member for most of my adult life (and with some forethought could have had a life time membership for $150 in 1967) I want to urge you to vote this year. I have not always paid close attention to these elections in the past mostly because I didn't know the people running for office and from their resumes there didn't seem to be much of difference among them so it didn't seem to matter so much. But that was before I realized how important the board members are in deciding policy for NCTM. Case in point. Most recently I was disappointed by the Board's decision to not invest in the future by looking at the cost of technology as too expensive and not worth the investment at annual meetings. Renting busses is also very expensive, but the board sees the urgency of paying the outrageous fees for busses, but not for the technological infrastructure necessary to help math educators take advantage of the what technology has to offer us as the collaborative and participatory nature of Web 2.0 continues to grow and be a dominant player in the real world, but not in our math classrooms. There are no panaceas in the technology promise, but the train is leaving us at the station as our math leaders at NCTM are still looking at technology as an expensive frill and not an integral part of what's needed in the math classroom. It already is a part of our students lives, so we need to help make it a part of our teacher's lives in the math classroom.  What I'm doing as an NCTM member is casting my vote for someone who in my opinion is a champion of viewing math education creatively through a technological lens. Ed Dickey was my chair person on the program committee for the 1999 San Francisco Annual meeting and had the foresight then to see that there needed to be a technology liason on the committee as we approached the new millenium with all its technological promise. I was fortunate enough to serve in that role and admired his effort to push the agenda towards a more innovative and creative future for mathematics education. Ed has also been good friend of CLIME over the years and always encouraged me and others to continue our efforts in support of the vision of how technology can serve the needs of the math educator community. So I encourage you to join me in voting for Ed Dickey as a new At-Large NCTM Board member of NCTM.  (For more details click here). Best wishes, -Ihor Ihor Charischak CLIME president Council for Technology in Math Education ihor@clime.org http://clime.org

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Testing your approximate number sense

CLIMEnotes: 9/16/08 Jerry Becker provided an interesting link this morning regarding an article in the NY Times: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2008/09/15/science/20080915_NUMBER_SENSE_GRAPHIC.html Always fun to see how the media takes advantage of technology to present an idea in an interesting and creative way.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Technology updates at NCTM: some signs of life?

Though the NCTM Board was adamant about not spending $$$ for wireless access in Washington, DC (see previous blog) there are signs of technological life at NCTM. Here are some examples:
  • Call for Manuscripts: 2010 Focus Issue: Learning and Teaching Mathematics through Technology. It sounds like the NCTM Editorial Board is interested in catching up with what's happening with technology in math by soliciting manuscripts for their Mathematics Teacher journal. Unfortunately, by the time these papers get published in 2010 most of the articles will need an update. This Web 1.0 strategy may need to be reimagined*.
  • Check Out NCTM's Math News Feed. Now you can keep up with what the media is saying about math education. Read the Council's scrolling news feed online, or subscribe to the RSS feed to have it delivered to your computer each day. Source: Member Update Newsletter
  • At the affiliate leadership meeting in Philly last month Hank Kepner (NCTM's new prez) encouraged members of CLIME and others to share ideas about how best to incorporate Web 2.0 (and other tech as tool) ideas in the teaching and learning math. I'll be sharing these ideas in future CLIME blogs. In the meantime please share your ideas with me. (Click on the envelop icon below.
* Dictionary.com tells me there is no such word as reimagined. Does that mean it belongs to the Web 2.0 lexicon? (I think so.)